Exploring FIDO vs FIDO2: Evolution in Secure Authentication

The importance of secure authentication cannot be overstated in today’s digital landscape. With cyber threats on the rise and traditional password-based systems proving increasingly vulnerable, there’s a pressing need for robust passwordless authentication standards.

Enter FIDO and FIDO 2 – two key players in the realm of online security. The FIDO Alliance passwordless FIDO and passwordless FIDO 2 authentication methods are changing the nature of authentication with standards for simpler, stronger authentication that define an open, scalable, interoperable set of mechanisms that reduce reliance on passwords.

When it comes to passwordless authentication, FIDO and FIDO 2 are quickly becoming the go-to standards. But what are the differences between the two methods and which one is the better fit for an organization? In this blog, we will delve into the differences between these two standards and explore how FIDO 2 represents an evolution in secure passwordless authentication.

Understanding FIDO (Fast Identity Online)

FIDO, which stands for Fast Identity Online, emerged as a response to the shortcomings of traditional password-based authentication methods. Introduced as an open standard, FIDO revolutionized online security by leveraging public-key cryptography to provide a more secure and user-friendly authentication experience.

DID YOU KNOW?
FIDO Alliance membership: As of March 2023, the FIDO Alliance boasts over 250 member organizations, including major technology companies, financial institutions, and government agencies. This widespread support indicates a significant industry push towards secure authentication solutions.

At its core, FIDO encompasses two main protocols:

• Universal Second Factor (U2F): Enables users to authenticate to online services using physical security keys, such as USB devices, providing an additional layer of protection beyond passwords.
• Universal Authentication Framework (UAF): Allows for authentication using biometrics or other local authenticators stored on the user’s device, such as fingerprint or iris scans.

How does the FIDO Authentication work?

FIDO (Fast Identity Online) is a set of open authentication standards designed to address the limitations of traditional password-based authentication systems by providing stronger security and improved user experience. FIDO works by leveraging public-key cryptography and a challenge-response mechanism to authenticate users securely.

Here’s a simplified explanation of how FIDO works:

Registration Phase
During the registration process, the user’s device generates a new key pair consisting of a public key and a private key. This key pair is unique to the device and is securely stored within a hardware-based secure element or software-based secure enclave. The public key is sent to the online service provider (e.g., a website) and associated with the user’s account. The private key remains on the user’s device and is never shared.

Authentication Phase
When the user attempts to log in to the online service, the service provider sends a challenge to the user’s device. The device generates a response to the challenge using the private key stored on the device. This response, along with the user’s public key, is sent back to the service provider. The service provider verifies the response using the public key associated with the user’s account. If the response is valid, the user is authenticated and granted access.

Key features and mechanisms of FIDO passwordless authentication include:

• Public-key cryptography: FIDO relies on asymmetric cryptography, where a pair of cryptographic keys (public and private) are used. The private key remains on the user’s device and is never shared, while the public key is provided to the service provider.
• Challenge-response mechanism: During authentication, the service provider sends a challenge to the user’s device. The device uses its private key to respond, and the service verifies it with the public key.
• Security keys or biometrics: FIDO authentication can be performed using USB security keys, biometric sensors (fingerprint, face), or built-in device authenticators.

By leveraging these mechanisms, FIDO passwordless authentication offers enhanced security, phishing protection, and a better user experience. It also promotes interoperability across different platforms and devices.

Enter FIDO 2: The Next Evolution

Building upon the foundation laid by FIDO, FIDO 2 represents a significant leap forward in secure authentication standards. FIDO 2 consists of two primary components:

• WebAuthn: Developed by W3C, this web authentication standard enables users to authenticate to websites using biometrics, USB security keys, or mobile devices. It ensures a high level of security while offering flexibility.
• CTAP (Client to Authenticator Protocol): Enables communication between the client device and external authenticators (e.g., security key). CTAP2 enhances this interaction for a seamless authentication experience.

FIDO vs FIDO 2: Key Differences and Benefits

While FIDO laid the groundwork for modern authentication standards, FIDO 2 introduces several key advancements that enhance security and usability:

• Enhanced Security: FIDO 2 strengthens protection against phishing, credential theft, and other threats.
• Improved Usability: It supports a wider range of authenticators, including mobile devices.
• Interoperability: FIDO 2 is designed for seamless integration across platforms and devices.

Conclusion

In today’s digital world where security threats are constantly evolving, FIDO and FIDO 2 represent essential pillars of online security. While FIDO introduced secure authentication through public-key cryptography, FIDO 2 builds upon this with WebAuthn and CTAP, offering greater security, usability, and interoperability.

As organizations and individuals seek to bolster their online defenses, embracing standards like FIDO 2 can play a crucial role in safeguarding sensitive data and ensuring a secure digital experience.

Learn more about OLOID's MFA solution!

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: What does FIDO stand for?
FIDO stands for Fast Identity Online. It’s a set of standards for secure online authentication that aims to replace passwords with more secure and convenient methods.

Q2: What are some examples of FIDO passwordless authentication methods?
FIDO passwordless authentication can be done using security keys like USB devices, or biometrics on your device, like fingerprint or facial recognition.

Q3: How does the FIDO 2 protocol work?
The FIDO 2 protocol uses a challenge-response mechanism with public-key cryptography. During login, the service sends a challenge to your device, which signs it with your private key stored securely on the device. The service verifies the response using your public key, granting access if valid.

Q4: What are Passkeys?
Passkeys are a sophisticated, FIDO passwordless login option for apps and websites. They consist of a private key stored on the user’s device and a public key with the service. This dual-key system verifies identity through encrypted biometrics or device PIN, eliminating the need for passwords or MFA codes.

Q5: What is a FIDO 2 security key?
A FIDO 2 security key is a physical device used to verify your identity when logging in. It adds an extra layer of security beyond passwords.

Q6: Is FIDO phishing resistant?
Yes. FIDO authentication is considered phishing resistant because decisions about credential use are handled by secure systems, not by the user’s judgment. FIDO/WebAuthn is the only widely available phishing-resistant authentication today.

Q7: What are FIDO2 devices, and how do they work?
FIDO2 devices are security keys that use public-key cryptography to authenticate users without passwords.

Here's how they work:

• Registration: A key pair is generated; the public key is stored on the service, and the private key stays on the device.
• Authentication: The service sends a challenge; the device signs it with the private key.
• Verification: The service uses the public key to verify the signature and grant access.

Advantages:

• Enhanced security: Strong cryptography makes them harder to compromise.
• Convenience: Easy to carry and use across services.
• Phishing resistance: Hardware-based security prevents spoofing.

Q8: Can I use FIDO authentication on my smartphone?
Yes. Many smartphones support FIDO authentication using built-in fingerprint sensors or face ID.

‍